[ 會員#20487 ] Y.S Tse
laparoscopy
病患者男 - 7歲
It is not understandable that laparoscopic hernia surgery with mesh is commended by the medical professionals for being much superior to open and mesh surgery, but the recurrence rate of laparoscopy surgery is double that of open surgery, for example, 2% vs 1%.. Why?
If the skills and experience of the surgeons are crucial, how can concerned patients get such information of the individual surgeons in order to alleviate some of their anxiety?
It is not understandable that laparoscopic hernia surgery with mesh is commended by the medical professionals for being much superior to open and mesh surgery, but the recurrence rate of laparoscopy surgery is double that of open surgery, for example, 2% vs 1%.. Why?
If the skills and experience of the surgeons are crucial, how can concerned patients get such information of the individual surgeons in order to alleviate some of their anxiety?
李泓暉醫生回覆:
26/10/2018
26/10/2018
Thank you for your question. I don't know where you got your data, but laparoscopic surgery for hernia carries the SAME risk of recurrence compared with traditional open surgery (0.5% according to literature).
Laparoscopic surgery wound is smaller than traditional surgery, and there may be less post operative pain, otherwise there is no significant difference in treatment outcome. Therefore, laparoscopic hernia surgery is not much superior to traditional surgery, and it is recommended only in recurrent or bilateral hernia cases.
You are correct that the skills and experience of surgeons are crucial, but there is no objective way to compare who's better than who. In general, hernia surgery is not complex, and most qualified surgery specialists in Hong Kong have enough experience.
Laparoscopic surgery wound is smaller than traditional surgery, and there may be less post operative pain, otherwise there is no significant difference in treatment outcome. Therefore, laparoscopic hernia surgery is not much superior to traditional surgery, and it is recommended only in recurrent or bilateral hernia cases.
You are correct that the skills and experience of surgeons are crucial, but there is no objective way to compare who's better than who. In general, hernia surgery is not complex, and most qualified surgery specialists in Hong Kong have enough experience.
以上資料只供參考，不能作診症用途，
請與家庭醫生查詢並作出適合治療。
如有身體不適請即求診，切勿延誤治療。
若資料有所漏誤，本網及相關資料提供者恕不負責。
請與家庭醫生查詢並作出適合治療。
如有身體不適請即求診，切勿延誤治療。
若資料有所漏誤，本網及相關資料提供者恕不負責。
Ken : 整合型微創疝氣手術
病患者男 - 33歲 想問在香港小腸氣手術是否只有" 傳統修補"和"人工補膜"? 因為我在台灣看到有".......Mr Chan : 包皮手術後包扎
病患者男 - 28歲 李醫生你後，前兩日在你診所做完包皮手術，回家後每次小便都弄濕紗布，需要馬上更換嗎？.......Tsui Pui Ching : 有關兒外科問題
病患者女 - 13個月 您們好！我有一個13個大的外孫女在温哥華，因早產時不能自行吃奶，初期用鼻喉餵奶，.......Sandra Wong : 有關腮線切除手術問題
病患者女 - 24歲 你好，今日我到公立醫院復診，醫生告知我是腮線良性腫瘤，要做手術切除。之前上網搜尋過.......samson : 包皮痴住龜頭
病患者男 - 18歲 將包皮反開 露出成個龜頭之後 正面（繫帶嘅反方向）會有三條肉筋痴住包皮同龜頭 用手.......Andy : 割包皮一個月水腫刺痛
病患者男 - 21歲 本人已割包皮一個月，採用的是一次性無縫包皮槍手術，傷口已大致愈合，但包皮的水腫仍然....... 發出提問使用細則
致李泓暉醫生 提問
